Ethical - Necessary

Rivalry Side A | Business | Other

Unethical - Invasion of Privacy

Rivalry Side B | Business | Other

Companies are now using GPS enabled phones to track their employees. Is this necessary or an invasion of privacy?

0

Posted by in Business / Other on 1/15/09
Debate Leaders
  1. ioneill (1 votes)
  1. AugTheCnqror (1 votes)

Side A fans: (9)

Neutral Fans: (0)


Side A Comment

AugTheCnqror - 2/23/09 @ 2:48 PM:
1
if they put it in a contract and you agree to it then fair is fair(name that movie), but it should be highly regulated. some people have to do a lot worse to keep their jobs, so if you want a job bad enough and thats a requirment then thats what you get.....it's capitalism baby, "it's my company and i can do what-ever th 4ell i want"

Side A Comment

markei - 1/24/09 @ 5:40 PM:
0
I think some of the responses are due to lowering of work ethic. Every company has a right to know if you are sitting in a restaurant for half the day or on the road doing your job, why not? After work hours, turn off the phone. It has to be a company provided phone for them to track you.
Production would go up if everyone knew they had to perform or be canned.

Side A Comment

Dennis Plucinik - 1/24/09 @ 4:42 PM:
0
I think it depends on the industry - they say in the software development industry, the one thing which returns the highest ROI in terms of worker productivity is their happiness, meaning they just plain produce better code.

This is why the Google offices have all the fricking bells and whistles

Side B Comment

Milky - 1/23/09 @ 10:43 PM:
0
I work a job where i clock in and out, and there are cameras everywhere except the bathroom "i think". Why would i want my employer to know where and what i do on my own time. That is definitely an invasion of privacy.

Side B Comment

MARV - 1/23/09 @ 7:36 PM:
0
if they had evidence that the employee was doing something wrong, it would b ok.

Side B Comment

big ben - 1/21/09 @ 9:11 PM:
0
I think that employees should be held accountable, however this is going over the line. I am old school. What happened to a good managament team who investigate trouble maker employees? Isn't this what they are payed to do?

Side A Comment

Outside MyBrain - 1/19/09 @ 9:25 AM:
0
I'm so torn on this one. As a business owner, I can see the value, but I can also see the issue of IofP. However, if the phones are company provided phones that have the ability to have the GPS turned off after hours, than I would say that there is nothing wrong with that.

What is the difference between that, and a boss calling or swinging by to "check up" on you?

I reiterate that tracking after hours, has some serious implications to it, so it is definitely a difficult scenario to fully judge unless one knew the parameters.

Side B Comment

ioneill - 1/18/09 @ 11:36 PM:
1
These kind of policies will not only breach privacy, it will breed a culture of distrust. This will make employees feel victimised and otherwise diligent employees will feel undervalued. A horrible way of running a business.

Side A Comment

Dennis Plucinik - 1/18/09 @ 10:59 PM:
0
Company time - companies should be able to protect their assets - some truck drivers even have video cameras mounted inside their cabs!? (seriously)

Side B Comment

Olivia Newton - 1/18/09 @ 8:19 PM:
0
And next we will have microchips implanted in our brains! I am concerned about our loss of personal privacy.
The Boss - 1/18/09 @ 8:23 PM: Ally | Side B
0
This is a stepping stone to just that Olivia. I'd be worried.

Side B Comment

hamdaniamin - 1/18/09 @ 8:17 PM:
0
I think this is too much. I understand how important is for our employee to be honest but to the extend checking them where they and what they do, that is too much.
The Boss - 1/18/09 @ 8:24 PM: Ally | Side B
0
Couldn't agree more.

Side A Comment

MLZupan - 1/18/09 @ 8:06 PM:
0
More and more employees are doing less and less and expecting to get paid more. If that is what it takes to for some accountability in their employees - then, go for it. As far as invasion of privacy - that is a mute point because it is not your time if you are the employee. When you sell yourself to an employee for a wage in exchange for a service over a particular time frame - what was once your time, now belongs to them (the employee). It is no longer your and until you are off the clock you don't have the right to do what ever you want, or go where ever you feel like going. If employees can't be responsible on their own then the employer must take measures that will either restrict movement, or enforce accountability - that is just business.
The Boss - 1/18/09 @ 8:22 PM: Rival | Side B
0
MLZupan,
I see your first point completely but why should the hard working employees be punished because of the lazy or unethical?

Also,
The company phone does come home with the employees which gives the employer access into personal time. Also, what If I decide to go shopping after work? Should they be able to follow me to the mall or liquor store?

Side A Comment

mama kaz - 1/18/09 @ 7:59 PM:
0
I think if more people did their job instead of cheating on hours and slacking off at work employers wouldn't even be considering such things. I worked with people who spent the whole day on the internet while I worked and took 2 and 3 hour lunches to boot.

Side B Comment

Jeff - 1/15/09 @ 11:51 PM:
0
Yep I agree with that too.

Side B Comment

cutie122403 - 1/15/09 @ 11:43 PM:
0
Plus, the supervisors should be keeping track of there people and their work to make sure they are where they say they are.

Side B Comment

Jeff - 1/15/09 @ 11:38 PM:
0
I would agree its all about BIG BROTHER

Side B Comment

The Boss - 1/15/09 @ 7:14 PM:
0
I understand the significance of the obscene amounts of money lost due to employees lying about hours and work completed but we've got to draw the line somewhere. I think this is a serious invasion of privacy.
cutie122403 - 1/15/09 @ 11:42 PM: Ally | Side B
0
I agree. There are so many dishonest employees out there but this is going a bit too far. They will probably end up spending more money on the gps for all the employees than it will be worth.
Add new comment:

You must either login or register before you can comment.

Side B fans: (16)

You need to be logged in to do that!
Login with Your Facebook Account:
Already have a JealousBrother account? Login
Register for a JealousBrother Account! Register