"Disagreeing has never been so much fun!"
All categories 
Entertainment
David Archuleta
David Cook
American Idol - Which David is your favorite?
Neutral Fans: (1)
View
Side A Comment
*lil_smarty* - 5/13/09 @ 6:09 PM:
i only love david A. he is sooo cute and he has a great voice.
Side A Comment
TattedAngel - 3/8/09 @ 12:47 AM:
I was hoping Archuleta would win, but since he didn't...I'm glad he has an album out! lol
Side B Comment
big ben - 2/16/09 @ 9:32 PM:
They both have great voices, but Cook has an alternative flavor that will capture more fans. America has a lot of alternative music fans.
Side A Comment
The Boss - 5/23/08 @ 5:20 PM:
I was blown away, I thought Archy had it. But David Cook will sell more albums regardless of whether he won or not.
Side B Comment
cutie122403 - 5/19/08 @ 11:32 AM:
I called it a long time ago that it would be these two at the very end.
Side A Comment
The Boss - 5/16/08 @ 6:34 PM:
I don't think Archuleta's dad is helping him very much. I like little Archuleta but Mr. Cook is going to win.
Side B Comment
cutie122403 - 5/13/08 @ 10:22 PM:
Alright as I watch each week I am leaning a little more towards David Cook now. Sorry Archuleta.
Side A Comment
The Boss - 4/30/08 @ 8:18 PM:
I'm a bit concerned that David Cook may be a bit &@!@$ David Archuleta seems like a genuinely nice kid. Go Archuleta!
Side B Comment
cutie122403 - 4/30/08 @ 7:56 PM:
This is a hard one. I love them both but I am thinking that David Cook will win. Archuleta is better vocally but Cook has more personaltiy.
