"Disagreeing has never been so much fun!"
All categories 
Entertainment
Tatiana Del Toro
Nick Mitchell
American Idol got it wrong with these two, which AI hopeful is the most annoying and pathetic contestant in the top 36?
Debate Leaders
AugTheCnqror
(1 votes)
Neutral Fans: (0)
Side A Comment
*lil_smarty* - 7/9/09 @ 6:05 PM:
the only thing i hate about her is her annoying laugh
Side A Comment
TattedAngel - 3/8/09 @ 12:37 AM:
My oh my oh my! That woman is a trip! I got irritated when she was put through to the wild-card show, but, very very veryyyyyyy happy to see her leave...though her exit was nothing sort of ridiculous! lol
I would love for Nick to make a comedy DVD. Hes funny s he can be, but not AI potential, so I'm glad he went home.
I would love for Nick to make a comedy DVD. Hes funny s he can be, but not AI potential, so I'm glad he went home.
Side B Comment
NaturallySwt - 3/1/09 @ 2:22 PM:
Can you say DRAMA QUEEN? I rather deal with a person who will make you laugh than someone who like a lightbulb-switches on and off!
Side B Comment
ksawyer - 2/27/09 @ 5:41 PM:
Nick has a really good voice - if you can get beyond the theatrics! I like him. Tatiana really has some issues.
Side A Comment
Tomegun - 2/26/09 @ 6:46 PM:
Ryan, she really didn't go home yet. They still have the wildcard show. She is mental and I think they only put her through to bring some character/drama to the show. I think we all agree, we would want to get away from her fast.
Nick is the man! I hope he makes it to the top 12.
Nick is the man! I hope he makes it to the top 12.
The Boss - 2/26/09 @ 7:32 PM:
Ally | Side A
Tom, I was trying to avoid thinking about her being included in the wild card show but you're right I don't think we're done with her yet. I really hope they bring that young black guy back, he was really good. (The one who was good friends with the guy who lost his wife)
I hope you're kidding about Nick. That guy is destroying the credibility of American Idol.
I hope you're kidding about Nick. That guy is destroying the credibility of American Idol.
Side A Comment
The Boss - 2/19/09 @ 12:13 AM:
Is it wrong that I got a little bit of pleasure seeing Tatiana go home? No, it's not. I'm very happy.
Side B Comment
big ben - 2/16/09 @ 9:30 PM:
The guy is off, but what the hell, he cracks me up! LOL I would rather hear two hyenas mating then here the girl's mouth.
Side A Comment
cutie122403 - 2/16/09 @ 10:29 AM:
Actually they both are really annoying. They should have never made it through.
Side A Comment
cutie122403 - 2/14/09 @ 12:14 AM:
I CANNOT stand this girl. She makes my stomach hurt.
Side A Comment
Koka Sexton - 2/12/09 @ 7:37 PM:
I'd rather watch the nutty guy than this nut job. Either way they are both going to get cut in a few weeks. They are only around for the ratings.
The Boss - 2/12/09 @ 9:11 PM:
Ally | Side A
I agree completely but that black guy was so much better than them and should have stuck around.
Side A Comment
mama kaz - 2/12/09 @ 7:34 PM:
I may stop watching american idol if they don't get her off of there pretty soon. She is the most annoying contestant they've ever had. She gives me a headache.
Side B Comment
Blabrmouth - 2/12/09 @ 5:26 PM:
At least the girl can sing. BTW, they tossed off the girl from Hi5 last night. Anyone with kids under 5 knows who I am talking about. Jen Hind
Side A Comment
The Boss - 2/11/09 @ 11:16 PM:
If this broad doesn't go home in the first week I am going to be very annoyed. Wait, I'm already annoyed. I'll be @@&#$! off. Wait, I'm already !#%%!! off. I'll be irate.
